April 7, 2025 from Medscape
Placebos Work — Even When You Know They’re Fake
It sounds impossible: a sugar pill that eases symptoms even when you’re told it’s a sugar pill. But that’s exactly what new research on PMS suggests.
A study published in BMJ Evidence-Based Medicine found that open-label placebos—those given without any deception—can still significantly reduce PMS symptoms. And the secret isn’t belief. It’s understanding.
Why PMS Was the Focus
Premenstrual syndrome (PMS) affects millions, yet remains under-treated and under-researched. The emotional and physical symptoms—irritability, cramps, mood swings—can disrupt daily life.
Past research shows the placebo effect accounts for up to 40% of PMS symptom relief. So, this study set out to test whether open-label placebos could tap into that effect, ethically.
The Power of Explanation
Researchers divided 150 participants into three groups:
- A control group (no treatment)
- A placebo group without explanation
- A placebo group with a 15-minute explanation of how placebos can work
The explanation included facts like:
- Placebos have been shown to relieve PMS symptoms
- Your brain may respond automatically to the act of taking a pill
- Placebos have no side effects
All participants tracked their symptoms over three menstrual cycles, with the placebo groups taking pills twice a day for six weeks.
Results That Speak Volumes
| Group | Symptom Intensity ↓ | Life Interference ↓ |
| Placebo + Explanation | 79.3% | 82.5% |
| Placebo (No Explanation) | 50.4% | 50.3% |
| Control (No Treatment) | 33% | 45.7% |
Just taking a placebo helped—but understanding why it could help made a massive difference.
Your Brain on Placebos
Studies using MRI and PET scans show that placebos:
- Increase dopamine and opioid activity
- Reduce pain signals in the brain
So even without a real drug, the body can generate a real response. It’s mind-body medicine in action.
So Why Aren’t Doctors Using This?
Because open-label placebo research is still relatively new. In Germany, pharmacies already offer placebo options. But in Canada and the U.S., there’s no official framework for prescribing them.
Luana Colloca, MD, PhD, a placebo researcher, says that needs to change. Colloca asks,
“If women improve with placebo, why expose them to medications with side effects?”
Trust and Transparency Matter
This study doesn’t just challenge how we see placebos—it challenges how we deliver care. Understanding the power of suggestion, conditioning, and honest communication could offer a new, low-risk tool in managing PMS and other chronic conditions.
Sometimes, what we know matters more than what we believe. And when it comes to PMS, relief might just come in a pill—with a conversation.
Considering an IME or document review to resolve an insurance claim, legal file, or workplace health and safety issue?
Our specialists provide evidence-based opinions, so get in touch with Western Medical today to learn more about our services.